Weft knitting can be done on two quite different machine families: circular machines, whose needles stand in a cylinder, and flat-bed machines, whose needles sit in a straight line. Both form loops course by course, as described in Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting. The difference is the shape of the needle bed. That decides whether the cloth comes off as a tube or as a panel, how many yarns can be knitted at once, and whether you are making fabric by the metre or a shaped garment.
The IIT Delhi NPTEL notes on knitting technology divide weft machines into flat-bed types (single bed, or double bed / V-bed) and circular-bed types. Errol Wood, in the University of New England lecture Machine Knitting, adds a third sector: fully fashioned straight-bar machines. This article compares the two everyday forms, circular and V-bed. Cut-and-sew, shaped panels and complete-garment knitting are covered in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting and How Sweaters Are Made.
Circular knitting machines
CottonWorks’ Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless course describes a circular weft machine as one that pulls yarn from creels, usually beside the machine, through guides, stop motions and feeders. Needles sit in grooves, or tricks, cut into the outside of a metal cylinder. Adjacent needles knit in sequence, and the cloth is formed as a tube, which then passes over a spreader and through take-up rolls.
Machine gauge is the number of tricks per linear inch. CottonWorks notes that cylinders of the same gauge but different diameters have different total needle counts. It gives 20–44 gauge for standard knits, ultra-fine work reaching 60, and 8–28 as common for cotton. Wood writes that available circular gauges range from 5 to 32 needles per inch, mostly finer than flat machines, and that 12–22 suits wool jersey. See Knitting Machine Gauge Explained. NPTEL states the usual motion: the cam jackets are generally stationary, and the cylinder rotates. A single-jersey machine has one needle set in the cylinder; a rib or double-jersey machine adds a dial at right angles. CottonWorks calls the gap between them the dial height, and states that it directly affects stitch length, and therefore weight, width and hand. Interlock is also a circular double-jersey structure; see Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.
The practical advantage is speed. Each feeder can add a course in one revolution. CottonWorks uses a 60-feeder example; Wood gives up to 144 circular feeds, against a maximum of 8 on a flat machine. The cost, he notes, is a slight bias: when every feeder knits, the wales are not quite perpendicular to the courses. On fine-gauge wool single jersey from singles yarn he also records spirality, which may return in the wash. The usual product is a length of tubular fabric, left as a tube or split to open width, then cut and sewn. Wood lists socks, seamless underwear and T-shirts as tubular uses, each size needing a machine of the appropriate diameter. CottonWorks describes a further family of seamless circular machines with smaller, body-sized cylinders, used for hosiery, socks and activewear.
Flat-bed (V-bed) knitting machines
On a flat-bed machine the needles stand in a straight line. CottonWorks states that the needle slots stay still and a carriage carries the cams across the needles. NPTEL says the same: the needles do not move sideways; a cam jacket reciprocates laterally, the exception being the straight-bar fully fashioned machine. Wood describes industrial V-bed machines as having two flat needle beds arranged as an inverted V. The English gauge is the number of needles per inch. His Table 12.1 gives V-bed gauges of 3–18 needles per inch and a typical bed width of 200 cm (78.7 inches). Most needles are latch needles; some machines use compound needles.
NPTEL states that a single bed produces plain, or single jersey, fabric, and that a V-bed produces rib and purl, and can also knit single jersey if one bed is not used. The needles on the two beds must be offset so that they do not collide. Wood states that a flat machine can start from one cone of yarn and knit a garment, and that it can knit any width within the needle bed. Pattern can be changed over a whole panel. The beds can be racked, that is, moved parallel to each other. CottonWorks calls the racking used to shape a panel “fashioning”. This reduces yarn and scrap, but it slows the machine and locks the shape early. Typical products are sweaters and flat-knit trims, such as polo collars.
A further step is complete-garment, or integral, knitting on special V-bed machines. CottonWorks describes this as knitting a whole garment on one machine, including buttonholes, pockets, collars and hems. Production is slower and more costly than other flat-bed methods, but waste and finishing steps are reduced. The routes are compared in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting.
How the two routes compare
The useful checks are the fabric form, the number of feeds, and whether the width can be changed. The table below is a qualitative comparison from those sources, not a set of laboratory results.
| Circular knitting | Flat (V-bed) knitting | |
|---|---|---|
| Yarn supply | Many packages; Wood gives the example of 96 cones | Can start from one cone |
| Needle bed | Cylinder; a dial is added for rib and interlock | One straight bed, or two beds in an inverted V |
| What moves | Usually the cylinder rotates past stationary cams | Needle bed stays still; the carriage and yarn carriers traverse |
| Fabric form | Always a tube; may stay tubular or be split to open width | Usually a flat panel; a tube can be knitted on both beds |
| Width | Fixed by cylinder diameter. Wood: usually about 30 inches (76 cm), up to 60 inches (152 cm) | Any width within the needle bed. Wood: typical bed 200 cm |
| Production, as described | Continuous motion and many feeds (Wood: up to 144; examples of 60–108) | Reciprocating carriage; Wood gives a maximum of 8 feeds |
| Patterning | Possible, but Wood describes typical patterns as small, repeated motifs | Pattern can be varied over a whole garment panel |
| Shaping | Limited on fabric machines; body-size machines can shape to a degree | Racking and stitch transfer used to fashion panels or complete garments |
| Typical products | T-shirts, underwear, hosiery, socks, jersey by the metre | Sweaters, cardigans, trims, scarves; also integral garments |
| Waste, as described | Cut-and-sew from split fabric always produces some waste; Wood records up to 25% in wool knitwear | Shaped panels or complete garments can reduce or eliminate cutting waste |
Neither machine is automatically better. A long run of T-shirt jersey or interlock underwear is a circular job. A shaped sweater, a polo collar, a short run in an expensive yarn, or a complete knitted garment is a flat-bed job.
Practical tips for a product developer
Choose the machine family from the garment, not from habit. If the product is a cut-and-sew T-shirt, polo or jersey dress, start with a circular fabric machine. Match cylinder diameter and gauge to the finished width and the yarn. More active feeders mean more courses per revolution, but also a slightly biased course line, which matters if stripes must stay square. Plan finishing for a tube or for split open-width fabric, and allow for edge curl on single jersey after cutting.
If the product is wool singles yarn in plain jersey, take Wood’s spirality warning seriously: a coarser gauge with a two-fold yarn, or a double-jersey structure, is often safer than hoping finishing will hold the fabric flat in the wash. If the product is a sweater, cardigan, scarf or a knit trim, start on a V-bed machine. Decide early whether you will cut blanks, fashion panels, or knit a complete garment. Fashioning and integral knitting save yarn, but they slow the machine and lock the shape before knitting starts. Body-size circular machines are the usual route for many socks and seamless underwear, but they do not replace a V-bed sweater machine. Common faults on both routes are covered in Common Knitting Faults and How to Fix Them.
FAQ
Are flat knitting and circular knitting both weft knitting? Yes. In both cases the yarn is formed into loops across the fabric, course by course. The difference is the needle bed. Warp knitting is a separate family; see Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting.
Why are circular machines faster? The motion is continuous, and many feeders can knit in one revolution. Wood contrasts that with the slower reciprocating carriage of a flat machine, and with the much smaller number of feeds on a flat bed.
Can a circular machine make a sweater? Wood lists jumpers and cardigans among circular products, but they are made from fabric, usually by cutting and sewing. Shaped sweater panels and complete knitted garments are V-bed work.
Can a V-bed machine knit a tube? Yes. Wood notes that it is possible, by using the front and back needles, to produce a tube of jersey.
What is the difference between a fabric machine and a garment machine? T. Palani Rajan, in the INFLIBNET chapter Weft Knitting, uses that split: some machines produce fabric, others produce garments. A large-diameter circular jersey machine is a fabric machine. A V-bed sweater machine and a body-size seamless circular machine are used as garment machines.
Do I need a different circular machine for every T-shirt size? For tubular garments that keep the knitted width, Wood says each size needs a machine of the appropriate diameter. If the tube is split to open-width fabric, one large-diameter machine can supply several sizes, with the usual cutting waste.
Is interlock knitted on a flat machine? No. Interlock as used for underwear and base layers is a circular double-jersey structure, made with cylinder and dial needles. See Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.
Conclusion
Circular and flat weft knitting use the same loop-forming principle, and often the same latch needle. They differ in the bed, the motion, the number of feeds, and the form of the cloth. Use a circular machine when you need metres of jersey, rib or interlock, or a body-size seamless tube. Use a V-bed machine when you need a shaped panel, a trim, a short run, or a complete knitted garment. The end use, not the familiarity of one machine, should decide.
Related reading
- Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting: Yarn Path, Machines and Fabrics
- Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock: The Basic Weft Knits
- How Sweaters Are Made: The Knitwear Production Process from Yarn to Finished Garment
- WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting
- Knitting Machine Gauge Explained: Needles, Yarn and Fabric
- Common Knitting Faults and How to Fix Them
Sources
- CottonWorks, Knit Basics (Cotton Incorporated): weft knitting by adjacent needles in sequence; circular machines forming a fabric tube, one revolution completing one course per yarn fed; flat-bed machines with needles in a straight line, one or two beds, used for sweaters, trims and scarves.
- CottonWorks, Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless: circular creels, stop motions, feeders, tricks and gauge; spreader and take-up of the fabric tube; standard, ultra-fine and cotton gauge ranges; 60-feeder example; dial height; V-bed carriage versus stationary needle slots; racking and fashioning; seamless circular (body-size cylinders, body mapping, reciprocal knitting for socks and hosiery); integral knitting on special flat-bed machines, including carrier and four-bed description, slower and more costly production, and reduced waste.
- NPTEL, Knitting Technology, introduction (IIT Delhi): weft machines as flat-bed (single or V-bed) or circular; cam jacket reciprocates on flat machines (exception: straight-bar); circular cams generally stationary with a rotating cylinder, or revolving cams on many small-diameter single-feeder machines; single bed for plain/jersey, V-bed for rib and purl and also for jersey; needles on two beds must be offset; circular rib uses cylinder and dial needles at right angles; interlock as two combined ribs.
- Errol Wood, Machine Knitting, WOOL482/582 (Australian Wool Education Trust / University of New England, 2012): weft sectors (fully fashioned, V-bed, circular); feeds and yarn carriers; circular bias of courses; maximum 8 feeds on flat machines and up to 144 on circular, with examples of 96 and of 72, 96 or 108 feeders and 25–50 mm of fabric per revolution; circular gauges in the text (5–32, wool jersey 12–22) and in Table 12.1 (circular 5–40, V-bed 3–18, typical V-bed width 200 cm, circular diameter usually about 30 inches and up to 60 inches); spirality in fine singles wool jersey; cut-and-sew waste up to 25% in wool knitwear; comparison of versatility, patterning, width control, tubular versus flat fabric, and waste.
- T. Palani Rajan, Weft Knitting, INFLIBNET e-book Textile manufacturing and testing: classification of weft knitting by machine frame (circular or flat), number of needle beds, end product (fabric machine or garment machine), basic structure and needle type.

