Colour Fastness Tests Explained: Washing, Rubbing, Light, Perspiration and Water

Colour fastness is a fabric’s ability to keep its colour, and to keep that colour to itself, when it is washed, rubbed, exposed to light, soaked by sweat or wetted by water. A T-shirt that fades after a few washes, dark jeans that rub colour onto a lighter fabric, or a shirt that fades in the sun all point to poor colour fastness. This guide explains the main tests in the ISO 105 series and their AATCC counterparts, how the grey scale ratings work, and what the grades mean when a buyer puts them in a specification.

Diagram of the grey scale for assessing change in colour. Nine pairs of grey chips are labelled grade 5, 4-5, 4, 3-4, 3, 2-3, 2, 1-2 and 1. In grade 5 both chips are identical; in each lower grade the lower chip is lighter, with colour differences of 0, 0.8, 1.7, 2.5, 3.4, 4.8, 6.8, 9.6 and 13.6 CIELAB units. An arrow runs from no change to large change.
The grey scale runs from grade 5, no change, to grade 1, a large change.

Two things every test measures

Most colour fastness tests report two separate results. The first is change in colour: how much the tested specimen has faded or shifted compared with an untested piece of the same fabric. The second is staining: how much colour has transferred onto white adjacent fabrics or a white rubbing cloth. The ISO washing, perspiration and water methods all assess both, by comparison with the grey scales or with an instrument. The ISO ISO 105-C06 washing test, for example, refers to ISO 105-A02, the grey scale for assessing change in colour, and ISO 105-A03, the grey scale for assessing staining, and to ISO 105-A04 and A05 for instrumental assessment.

Staining needs something to stain. ISO 105-C06 uses either a multifibre adjacent fabric, one white fabric made from several different fibres, or two single-fibre adjacent fabrics. The perspiration standard ISO 105-E04 gives the pairing rule for single-fibre fabrics: one piece is the same fibre as the test fabric, and the second follows a table. If the first piece is cotton, the second is wool; for wool or silk, the second is cotton; for viscose, wool; for polyamide, polyester and acrylic, wool or cotton.

How the grey scale works

The grey scale for change in colour is defined in ISO 105-A02. Its essential form has five pairs of grey chips illustrating grades 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1. A 9-step version adds the half grades 4–5, 3–4, 2–3 and 1–2. In each pair the first chip is a neutral grey; in grade 5 the second chip is identical, and in the lower grades it is increasingly lighter. The standard defines each step as a CIELAB colour difference:

Grade 54–543–432–321–21
CIELAB difference 00.81.72.53.44.86.89.613.6

To assess, the original fabric and the tested specimen are placed side by side in the same plane, with the grey scale nearby. ISO 105-A02 asks for a neutral grey surround of about Munsell N5, north-sky light or an equivalent source of 600 lx or more, light falling at about 45°, and viewing roughly perpendicular to the surface. The grade is the pair whose contrast matches the contrast between original and tested fabric. A 5 is given only when there is no perceived difference at all.

The staining scale (ISO 105-A03) works the same way but compares the stained white fabric with unstained white. In both scales, 5 is best and 1 is worst. Light fastness is the exception: it uses a different, 1 to 8 scale, explained below.

Colour fastness to washing

ISO 105-C06 covers domestic and commercial laundering of normal household articles with a reference detergent. A specimen sewn to its adjacent fabric is laundered, rinsed and dried in a small stainless steel container, with a low liquor ratio and steel balls of about 6 mm diameter providing the abrasive action. The standard states that one single (S) test closely approximates one domestic or commercial laundering. One multiple (M) test may in some cases approximate up to five launderings at temperatures not exceeding 70 °C; M tests are more severe because of the extra mechanical action. The methods do not reflect the effect of optical brighteners in commercial detergents, and they are designed for the specified reference detergents: the AATCC 1993 Standard Reference Detergent without optical brightener, or the ECE reference detergent.

The choice of multifibre fabric follows the temperature. ISO 105-C06 uses a multifibre fabric containing wool and acetate for tests at 40 °C and 50 °C (and in some cases 60 °C), and one without wool and acetate for certain 60 °C tests and all tests at 70 °C and 95 °C.

The American equivalent is AATCC TM61, Colorfastness to Laundering: Accelerated. AATCC’s summary of TM61 states that the colour loss and surface changes from five typical hand or home launderings, with or without chlorine, are roughly approximated by one 45-minute test.

Real laundering can still differ from the lab. Cotton Incorporated’s bulletin Producing Colorfast Cotton Knits says the AATCC 61-2A wash is a very good tool for predicting catastrophic failure of a shade, for example showing that direct dyes are not fast to home laundering, but that it is not sufficient to show how a garment’s colour will perform over extended home launderings. Its long-term laundering work found that reactive dyes performed better than vat, direct and sulfur dyes in today’s home laundering, and that dyes with multiple reactive anchors performed better than single-anchor types. See Reactive Dyes for Cotton and Vat Dyes for Cotton.

The same bulletin flags chlorine. Municipal water contains low levels of chlorine for sanitation, usually up to 3.0 ppm, and cold tap water tends to hold more than hot. Detergents usually contain a chlorine scavenger, but the cold rinses after the wash do not, so dyes should have good chlorine fastness. The bulletin adds that the shading components of a recipe, such as the red and yellow in a navy, matter as much as the main dye: if one fades, the whole shade changes.

Colour fastness to rubbing (crocking)

Rubbing fastness, also called crocking, measures colour that rubs off onto other materials. ISO 105-X12 applies to textiles of all fibres, as yarn or fabric, dyed or printed, including floor coverings. Two tests are made, one with a dry rubbing cloth and one with a wet one. For most textiles a 16 mm diameter rubbing finger presses with a force of 9 N and moves to and fro along a 104 mm track, 10 times to and 10 times fro at one cycle per second, carrying a 50 mm square of white cotton rubbing cloth. Pile fabrics use a rectangular 19 mm × 25.4 mm finger instead, and the standard notes there is no known correlation between the results of the two fingers.

For wet rubbing, the cloth is soaked to a take-up of 95–100%, although the standard notes that the soak level can dramatically affect ratings and that (65 ± 5)% is a very commonly used level. That is why a wet rubbing result should always be reported with its soak level. Specimens are cut in both the warp and weft directions, and the staining of the rubbing cloth is graded with the grey scale for staining.

AATCC’s TM8, Colorfastness to Crocking: Crockmeter, does the same job with white crock test cloth, dry and wet. AATCC grades the transferred colour with the Gray Scale for Staining or the Chromatic Transference Scale, does not recommend the method for carpets or for very small print areas, and notes that because washing, drycleaning, ironing or finishing can change colour transfer, the test may be done before, after, or before and after such treatments. ISO 105-X12 names AATCC TM8 as a suitable apparatus for its standard finger.

Colour fastness to light

ISO 105-B02 exposes textiles to a xenon arc lamp representative of natural daylight (D65). It also applies to white, bleached or optically brightened textiles. Light fastness is not graded against the grey scale alone. The specimen is exposed together with a set of blue wool references and rated by comparison with them.

Two reference sets are allowed. The European blue wool references run from 1 (very low light fastness) to 8 (very high light fastness), and each higher-numbered reference is approximately twice as fast as the one before. The American references are L2 to L9. ISO 105-B02 states that the results from the two sets may not be identical, so a light fastness grade must always state which set was used. The AATCC counterpart for xenon testing is TM16.3, Colorfastness to Light: Xenon-Arc. AATCC’s summary makes an important point: its test options do not imply an accelerated test for a specific application, and the relationship between any lightfastness test and real exposure must be agreed by the contracting parties. Dye choice for polyester is covered in Disperse Dyes for Polyester.

Colour fastness to perspiration

ISO 105-E04 tests resistance to human perspiration. The specimen is tested twice, in two freshly made solutions containing L-histidine, sodium chloride and phosphate: an alkaline solution at pH 8.0 and an acid solution at pH 5.5. A 40 mm × 100 mm specimen, sewn to its adjacent fabric, is soaked for 30 minutes at room temperature at a liquor ratio of about 50:1. It is then held between glass or acrylic plates under 12.5 kPa and kept in an oven for 4 hours at 37 °C, before drying in air at no more than 60 °C. Colour change and staining are then graded.

The AATCC method, TM15, Colorfastness to Perspiration, differs: it tests acid perspiration only. AATCC’s summary explains that earlier versions had both acid and alkaline tests, but the alkaline test was dropped after committee work showed the acid test correlates with limited field studies. This is a clear example of why an ISO result and an AATCC result for the same property are not the same thing. For dyes used on wool, silk and nylon, see Acid Dyes for Wool, Silk and Nylon.

Colour fastness to water

ISO 105-E01 covers immersion in water. The specimen with its adjacent fabric is immersed in water, drained, placed between plates under the same 12.5 kPa pressure and held for 4 hours at 37 °C. Colour change and staining are graded as before. AATCC states that its TM107, Colorfastness to Water, is technically equivalent to ISO 105-E01, and that it uses distilled or deionized water because tap water varies in composition.

The main tests at a glance

Property ISO method AATCC method What is graded Key conditions (ISO)
Washing ISO 105-C06 TM61 Colour change and staining, grey scales 5–1 S test about one laundering; M test up to five at no more than 70 °C
Rubbing (crocking) ISO 105-X12 TM8 Staining of the rubbing cloth, dry and wet 9 N, 16 mm finger, 104 mm track, 10 cycles; report wet soak level
Light ISO 105-B02 TM16.3 (xenon) Fading against blue wool references Xenon arc, daylight D65; references 1–8 or L2–L9
Perspiration ISO 105-E04 TM15 Colour change and staining Acid pH 5.5 and alkaline pH 8.0; 12.5 kPa; 4 h at 37 °C (AATCC TM15: acid only)
Water ISO 105-E01 TM107 Colour change and staining Immersion; 12.5 kPa; 4 h at 37 °C

What the grades mean for buyers

A fastness grade only makes sense with its method. “Washing fastness 4” tells you little unless you know whether it was ISO 105-C06 or AATCC TM61, which test condition, and whether the 4 refers to colour change or to staining on a particular fibre of the multifibre strip. The same applies to rubbing (dry or wet, and at what soak level) and to light (blue wool 1–8 or L2–L9). A good specification names the method, the test condition and the minimum grade for each result.

Read the grades as visual steps. Grade 5 means no perceived difference; grade 4 corresponds to a CIELAB difference of 1.7 on the change-in-colour scale; grade 3 to 3.4; grade 1 to 13.6. The steps are not equal, so going from 4 to 3 is a bigger change than going from 5 to 4–5. The test methods describe how to test and grade; the minimum grade for a product is set in the buyer’s specification.

Practical points for a mill or a merchandiser:

  • Choose the dye class and recipe for the fastness you need. Cotton Incorporated calls dye selection the number one consideration for colourfast cotton.
  • Check every component of the shade, not only the main dye, because a fading shading dye changes the whole colour.
  • Remember that a fuzzy surface makes a fabric look lighter. Cotton Incorporated reports black interlock that had lost an average of 8.7% colour strength after 20 launderings regained almost all of it after a cellulase treatment removed the surface fuzz. See Fabric Pilling.
  • Test after any finishing that could change the result, as AATCC TM8 allows for crocking.
  • Keep the test method the same from development to bulk, and record the conditions with every result.

FAQ

What is a good colour fastness grade? On the grey scales, 5 is the best possible result and means no visible change or staining. The minimum acceptable grade is set by the buyer’s specification for that product.

What is the difference between ISO 105 and AATCC methods? They are separate families of standards for the same properties. Conditions differ: AATCC TM15, for example, tests acid perspiration only, while ISO 105-E04 tests acid and alkaline. Results from one should not be reported as if they came from the other. For light fastness, ISO 105-B02 itself warns that the two sets of blue wool references may not give identical results.

Why are dry and wet rubbing reported separately? ISO 105-X12 makes them two separate tests, one with a dry cloth and one with a wet cloth. It also notes that the soak level of the wet cloth can dramatically affect the rating, so the soak level should be reported too.

Why is light fastness graded 1 to 8 instead of 1 to 5? Light fastness is rated against eight blue wool references, each about twice as fast as the one before, rather than against the five-step grey scale alone.

Does one AATCC TM61 test equal five washes? AATCC says one 45-minute test roughly approximates the colour loss and surface change of five typical home launderings. Cotton Incorporated adds that it predicts catastrophic failures well but is not enough on its own to show performance over extended home laundering.

What is a multifibre fabric? A white adjacent fabric containing strips of several fibres, used in washing, perspiration and water tests so that staining on each fibre type can be graded at once.

Conclusion

Colour fastness testing asks two questions: does the colour change, and does it move onto something else? The ISO 105 and AATCC methods answer them for washing, rubbing, light, perspiration and water under controlled conditions, and the grey scales and blue wool references turn the answers into grades. A grade is only meaningful with its method and conditions, so specify them, test the same way each time, and choose dyes and processes that will meet them.

Sources

Knit vs Woven Fabric: Differences, Stretch, Examples and Uses

Almost every garment fabric is either knitted or woven. A T-shirt, a hoodie and a pair of leggings are knits. A dress shirt, a pair of jeans and a canvas tote bag are wovens. The two look similar from a distance, but they are built in completely different ways, and that construction decides how the fabric stretches, recovers, drapes, wrinkles, shrinks and wears. This guide explains the difference, gives examples of each, and shows how to tell them apart and which to choose for a given product.

Side-by-side diagram of woven and knitted fabric. Left: a plain weave, with blue warp yarns running lengthwise and orange weft yarns running across, passing over and under each other at right angles; labelled firm and stable, little stretch. Right: a single jersey knit, with rows of interlocking loops labelled course (row of loops) and wale (column); labelled loops open up, so the fabric stretches.
A woven fabric interlaces two sets of yarns, while a knit is built from rows of loops.

How woven fabric is made

CottonWorks, the Cotton Incorporated learning hub, describes weaving as interlacing two sets of yarns. One set runs along the length of the fabric: these are the warp yarns, also called ends. The other set runs across the width: the weft yarns, also called picks or filling. The warp unwinds from a loom beam and is held under tension, and groups of warp yarns are raised and lowered to open a gap, the shed, through which each weft yarn is inserted.

Because the warp works under that tension, it needs preparation. CottonWorks explains that spun warp yarns are usually slashed, or sized, with a film of starch or a starch and PVA blend to reduce hairiness, improve abrasion resistance and increase strength. The National Cotton Council’s From Field to Fabric adds that warp yarns usually need a higher twist than filling yarns, and that some modern shuttleless machines carry filling across the loom at more than 2,000 metres per minute. An Oregon State University Extension guide, The Structure of Woven, Knit, and Other Fabrics, notes that the warp yarns are stronger and less flexible than the weft. The warp direction is the lengthwise grain, the weft is the cross grain, and the finished side edges are the selvages.

All woven designs are built from three basic weaves, according to CottonWorks: plain, twill and satin.

  • Plain weave (1/1): each warp yarn goes over one weft and under the next. It has the most interlacing points, so it tends to be stiffer with less drape, but it is very stable, with few problems of skew, seam slippage or snagging. Examples include chambray, broadcloth, canvas and sheeting, and the Oregon State guide adds chiffon, voile, muslin, gingham, duck and burlap at different weights.
  • Twill: a diagonal line on the face. CottonWorks notes that a 3/1 twill has longer floats and fewer interlacing points, giving higher tear strength, and is used for bottom-weight fabrics such as denim, chino and gabardine. See Jeans Fabric: Denim Twill, Indigo Warp and Weight.
  • Satin: long floats with no twill line, giving a smooth, lustrous surface and excellent drape, but CottonWorks warns of picking, snagging, skew and seam slippage. The National Cotton Council calls satin the least common of the three; cotton sateen is an example.

How knitted fabric is made

CottonWorks’ Knit Basics describes knits as made by intermeshing yarn into loops. A horizontal row of loops is a course and a vertical column is a wale. All knits are built from three core stitches: knit, tuck and float. Knitting yarns run at low tension, so they need less twist than weaving yarns, and they are usually waxed to reduce yarn-to-metal friction, which means knitted fabric needs finishing to remove the wax.

There are two families. In weft knitting, neighbouring needles knit one after another across the fabric from the same yarn, on circular or flat-bed machines. CottonWorks states that weft knits have more horizontal stretch and that the fabric curls, runs and unravels at both ends. In warp knitting, each loop is formed from separate lengthwise yarns fed from a beam, and the needles knit at the same time. Warp knits have more vertical stretch, suit swimwear, activewear, hosiery and intimates, and do not fray or curl when cut horizontally. Tricot and raschel are the main types. The two families are compared in Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting, and the machines in Flat Knitting vs Circular Knitting.

The National Cotton Council gives a sense of scale. Circular machines that produce tubular fabric usually range from 9 to 60 inches in cylinder diameter, and a 32-inch machine for underwear knits can have over 2,700 needles and 128 cones of yarn feeding at once.

Stretch and recovery

Stretch is the biggest practical difference. CottonWorks contrasts woven constructions, which are rigid and stable, with knits, whose intermeshed loops let the fabric stretch to fit the body. A teaching note from Government Polytechnic Bhadrak, Textile Design I, makes the same comparison: woven fabric is comparatively more rigid and less stretchable, and knitted fabric less rigid and more stretchable.

Stretch is only half the story. The Oregon State guide stresses recovery, the fabric’s ability to return to its size after being stretched. Single jersey has its greatest stretch in the crosswise direction but lacks the stretch recovery of some other knits, so it should be checked for both. Rib knits are bulkier but recover better. Double knits, including interlock, are firmer, less stretchy and more stable than single knits; interlock stretches less than a single rib but more than other double knits. The basic structures are covered in Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.

Wovens can be made to stretch by adding spandex (elastane). Cotton Incorporated’s bulletin Wet Processing of Cotton/Spandex Fabric explains that in wovens the spandex can be in the filling, the warp or both, usually as a core-spun yarn, and that the fabric construction largely decides how much stretch is possible. It gives typical stretch levels of 15–50 percent for woven structures with spandex, against 50–100 percent for cotton knits with spandex. Stretch jeans are a common example. That stretch comes from the fibre, not from the weave itself.

Knit vs woven at a glance

The table summarises the sources above. These are general tendencies: a tight double knit can be firmer than a loose plain weave, so always test the actual fabric.

Woven fabric Knitted fabric
Construction Two yarn sets, warp and weft, interlaced at right angles Yarn formed into intermeshed loops, in courses and wales
Yarn twist Warp usually higher twist than filling; spun warp is sized Lower twist, low tension; yarn is often waxed
Stretch Rigid and stable; with spandex, typically 15–50% stretch Stretches and conforms to the body; weft knits mainly widthwise, warp knits mainly lengthwise; cotton knits with spandex typically 50–100%
Recovery and shape Good dimensional stability Varies: rib recovers well, single jersey less; dimensional stability generally poorer
Wrinkling Lower crease resistance Smoother appearance in wear; higher crease resistance
Handle and air Stiffer; less porous Softer; more porous and air permeable
Cut edges Finished side edges (selvages) Weft knits curl, run and unravel; warp knits do not fray or curl when cut across
Pilling and snagging Satin floats can snag; plain weave has few snagging issues Lower-twist yarn, which pills more readily (see our pilling article)
Typical garments Broadcloth, chambray, gingham, canvas, denim, chino, gabardine, sheeting T-shirts, polos, sweaters, hoodies, joggers, leggings, sports bras, fleece

Examples and uses

CottonWorks lists t-shirts, polos, sweaters, hoodies, joggers, tights, leggings, sports bras and fleece as common knit garments, and says knits suit products that need stretch, movement or comfort. Knit textures come from mixing yarns and the three stitches: tuck stitches, for example, are the basis of pique for golf and tennis shirts, and floated loops can be napped to make fleece.

Wovens dominate where shape, crispness and strength matter. The National Cotton Council lists gingham, percale, chambray and batiste as plain weaves, and denim, gabardine, herringbone and ticking as sturdy twills. CottonWorks names denim, chino and gabardine as 3/1 twill bottom-weight fabrics. The Oregon State guide adds velvet, velveteen, terry and corduroy among the pile and other weave variations.

The choice is not always obvious. CottonWorks notes that warp knits can be very fine, and the Oregon State guide describes warp knitting as giving a durable, run-proof, flatter and less bulky fabric than weft knitting. The same guide says double knits are often cut with patterns meant for wovens rather than for stretchy knits.

Care differences

Construction affects how a garment survives washing. The Government Polytechnic Bhadrak note rates woven fabric as dimensionally stable and knitted fabric as poorer. Cotton Incorporated adds that cotton/spandex knits should be relaxed before dyeing to improve dimensional stability. For causes and controls, see Fabric Shrinkage: Why It Happens and How to Control It. Knits are also usually made from lower-twist yarn, and low twist is one of the main causes of pilling, as explained in Fabric Pilling: Causes, Prevention, Testing and Removal.

Wovens hold their shape, but they crease more readily. Easy-care and durable press finishes are one way mills reduce creasing in cotton wovens; see Wrinkle-Free and Durable Press Finishing. In every case, the care label for the finished garment is the guide to follow.

How to tell knit and woven apart

  • Look closely at the surface. On a single jersey knit, the Oregon State guide says the face shows the V of the knit loop and the back shows the horizontal part of the loop. CottonWorks describes these as the legs and the crowns. On a woven, you see yarns crossing over and under each other at right angles, in a grid (plain), a diagonal line (twill) or a smooth float surface (satin).
  • Stretch it gently across the width. A weft knit gives noticeably, and a good one springs back. A woven without spandex is rigid and barely moves.
  • Check a cut edge. CottonWorks notes that weft knits curl and can run and unravel. Look along the length for a selvage, the finished edge that marks a woven.
  • Look for a tube. CottonWorks notes that a circular knitting machine produces fabric as a continuous tube, so tubular fabric is a knit.

Which is better for what?

Neither construction is better overall. Choose a knit when the garment must move with the body, feel soft next to the skin, or fit closely without darts or fastenings: T-shirts, underwear, sportswear, sweaters and leggings. Choose a woven when the garment must hold a crisp shape, keep its dimensions, take a sharp crease or resist hard wear: shirts, tailored trousers, jeans, workwear and bags. Within each family, the yarn and structure matter as much as the category. A stable interlock or a warp knit can do jobs once reserved for wovens, and stretch wovens borrow some comfort from knits.

FAQ

Is jersey knit or woven? Knit. Single jersey is the basic weft-knit structure, with V-shaped loops on the face.

Is denim knit or woven? Woven. Denim is a twill; CottonWorks lists it among the 3/1 twill bottom-weights.

Which stretches more, knit or woven? Knit, in general. Even with spandex, Cotton Incorporated gives typical stretch of 15–50 percent for wovens and 50–100 percent for cotton knits.

Is knitted fabric weaker than woven? The Government Polytechnic Bhadrak note rates woven fabric as stronger and more durable, and knitted fabric as comparatively weaker. Real performance depends on the yarn, the structure and the test, so compare fabrics with the same test method; see Fabric Testing.

Which wrinkles less? Knits. CottonWorks says the mobility of knit loops helps knitted fabrics keep a smoother appearance than wovens.

Can a woven fabric be stretchy? Yes. Spandex, usually as a core-spun yarn in the filling, the warp or both, gives woven goods such as stretch jeans their stretch and recovery.

Conclusion

Woven fabric interlaces two sets of straight yarns; knitted fabric loops one set of yarn through itself. That single difference explains why wovens are firm, stable and crisp, and why knits stretch, recover, feel soft and fit the body. Pick the construction from the job the garment must do, then pick the yarn, structure and finish to suit it.

Sources

  • CottonWorks, Weaving Basics (Cotton Incorporated): warp and weft (ends, picks, filling); warp tension and the shed; plain, twill and satin as the basic weaves; slashing of spun warp yarns with starch or starch/PVA size.
  • CottonWorks, Basic Woven Fabric Designs: plain weave properties and examples; 3/1 twill tear strength and bottom-weight uses; satin lustre, drape and its problems.
  • CottonWorks, Knit Basics: knits versus wovens; common knit garments; courses, wales, legs and crowns; knit, tuck and float stitches; low-twist, waxed knitting yarns; weft and warp knit stretch direction, curling, running and fraying.
  • National Cotton Council, From Field to Fabric: Fabric Manufacturing: warp twist; shuttleless filling insertion above 2,000 m per minute; plain, twill and satin examples; wales and courses; circular cylinder diameters of 9 to 60 inches; the 32-inch, 2,700-needle, 128-cone example.
  • Ardis W. Koester, The Structure of Woven, Knit, and Other Fabrics (Oregon State University Extension Service, 1976): warp and weft grain and selvages; plain weave examples by weight; single jersey, rib, double knit and interlock stretch and recovery; warp knits.
  • Cotton Incorporated, Wet Processing of Cotton/Spandex Fabric (technical bulletin TRI 3012): spandex in knits and wovens; core-spun spandex in wovens; typical stretch 50–100 percent for cotton knits and 15–50 percent for wovens; relaxing knits before dyeing for dimensional stability.
  • Textile Design I, lecture note (Government Polytechnic Bhadrak, Textile Engineering): comparison table of woven and knitted structures (rigidity, stretch, crease resistance, handle, porosity, strength, dimensional stability).

Fabric Pilling: Causes, Prevention, Testing and Removal

Pilling is the small, fuzzy balls of fibre that appear on a sweater, a jersey T-shirt or a pair of joggers after some wear and washing. Woolmark calls it bobbling and describes it as giving clothing an unsightly or worn-out appearance. For a mill or knitwear factory it is a property that can be designed in or out long before the garment reaches a shop.

This article covers why pills form, what spinners, knitters and finishers can do about them, how laboratories grade pilling, and how to remove pills from clothes you own.

Four-step diagram of how a pill forms on fabric. 1 Fuzz: fibre ends tease out of the yarn surface. 2 Entanglement: loose fibres tangle into a small ball. 3 Growth: the pill gathers more fibre and is held to the yarn by anchor fibres. 4 Wear-off: weak anchor fibres break and the pill drops off. A note below says strong fibres such as polyester, nylon and acrylic keep pills on the fabric, while cotton and wool pill sooner but the pills are more likely to break away.
Self-made diagram for this article. Qualitative only: the four stages follow Saraf and Tayade (International Dyer & Finisher, 2019) and the introduction to ISO 12945-2:2020; the strong-fibre versus weak-fibre note follows AWTA Product Testing.

What is pilling?

The international pilling standard, ISO 12945-2:2020, defines a pill as an entangling of fibres into balls that stand proud of the fabric and are so dense that light will not pass through them and they cast a shadow. Pilling is the generation of those pills over the fabric surface. The same standard separates two related surface changes. Fuzzing is the roughing up or teasing out of surface fibres. Matting is the disorientation of the raised fibres of a napped fabric. All three can happen during washing, dry cleaning or wearing.

A pill is not the same as loose lint. AWTA Product Testing describes pilling as the entanglement of fibres that have worked loose and pulled out from yarns during wear and laundering. The pill stays attached to the fabric because some of its fibres are still held in the yarn.

How a pill forms

Naresh Saraf and Priti Tayade, writing in International Dyer & Finisher, divide the process into four stages: fuzz formation, entanglement, growth and wear-off. The ISO 12945-2 introduction describes the same thing as three parallel processes: fibre entanglement leading to pill formation, development of more surface fibre, and fibre and pill wear-off.

The balance between formation and wear-off explains why different fibres behave so differently. ISO 12945-2 gives two extremes. With a strong fibre, pills form faster than they wear off, so pilling keeps increasing with wear. With a weak fibre, formation competes with wear-off, so the amount of pilling rises and falls. In some constructions the surface fibres wear off before pills can form at all.

Pills appear where the garment is rubbed most. Woolmark lists the elbows, armpits, sleeves, belly and the sides of a sweater, where the arms keep touching the body. Saraf and Tayade add collars, cuffs, and the thighs and seat of trousers. Woolmark also notes that an active wearer, or a garment that constantly rubs against another surface, for example when sitting at a desk for long periods, is more likely to pill.

Why some fabrics pill more than others

Saraf and Tayade name the main drivers as fibre, yarn twist, fabric construction, processing, the wearer’s habits and the environment of use. A product developer controls the first four.

Fibre type and strength

AWTA explains that synthetic fibres such as polyester, acrylic and nylon are relatively strong compared with cotton and wool. Pills from natural fibres generally appear sooner but are more likely to wear or break away. Fabrics made from synthetic fibres are more likely to keep their pills. A blend of the two can be the worst case: the natural fibre forms the pills and the synthetic fibre anchors them in place. Saraf and Tayade make the same point about blends of strong and relatively weak fibres. For a wider view of fibre properties, see Textile Fibres: Natural, Regenerated and Synthetic Types.

Fibre fineness matters too. Saraf and Tayade state that fine-denier fibres tend to pill more because they are less stiff. They also note that fibres with very low fibre-to-fibre friction slip out of the yarn more easily, which gives more surface fibre to tangle.

Staple length and spinning route

Filament yarns, in which every filament runs the whole length of the yarn, typically do not pill, AWTA notes, because no fibre ends sprout from the surface. Pilling is a problem of staple yarns. Shorter fibres work loose more easily. Combing removes short fibres and keeps the longest ones, while carded-only yarns contain a higher share of short fibre. AWTA also notes that open-end (rotor) yarns are spun directly from sliver and tend to contain shorter fibres than ring-spun yarns.

Ring spinning has a trade-off. Cotton Incorporated’s bulletin Producing Colorfast Cotton Knits states that, of the yarn systems used for cotton, ring spinning gives the hairiest yarn, but also the softest and strongest one. Hairiness is the raw material of fuzz, so a ring-spun knit often needs a finishing step to keep its surface clean. Yarn count also affects how fine and how hairy a yarn is; see Yarn Count Systems Explained.

Twist and ply

AWTA calls twist possibly the biggest single factor after fibre content. Lower twist gives a softer handle but a higher tendency to pill. Higher twist gives a harder feel but less pilling. Plying helps as well: a single-ply yarn is more likely to pill than a two-ply yarn, and a two-ply yarn more than a cabled construction made by folding plied yarns together. Woolmark gives the same advice for wool designers: use the highest twist factor you can handle.

Fabric structure: why knits pill more

Whether a fabric is woven or knitted, AWTA states that the tightness of the structure decides how easily fibres can work out of the yarn. Knitted fabrics generally use softer, lower-twist yarn for handle, and the knitted structure gives the fibres more surface area to break free. Cotton Incorporated likewise notes that knits are usually more loosely constructed than wovens, from lower-twist, bulkier yarns. Saraf and Tayade explain that pilling is often more noticeable on knits such as sweaters because the distance between yarn crossings is greater than in a woven fabric, and that a very tight construction such as denim usually pills very little.

For knitwear, that points to stitch density and machine gauge. Woolmark recommends fabrics with a higher cover factor. In practice that means choosing a gauge and stitch length that suit the yarn, rather than knitting the yarn loosely. See Knitting Machine Gauge Explained and Knitting Yarns for Knitwear Compared.

Pilling factors at a glance

The table summarises the factors above. It is a qualitative guide drawn from the sources, not a set of test results. A change that reduces pilling often costs something else, usually softness.

Factor More likely to pill Less likely to pill Trade-off or note
Yarn type Staple (spun) yarn Continuous filament yarn AWTA: filament yarns typically do not pill
Fibre length Short fibres; carded-only or open-end yarn Long fibres; combed yarn AWTA: carded-only yarn has more short fibre
Fibre strength Strong synthetics keep their pills; strong/weak blends Weaker fibres, where pills break away; low-pill (brittle) synthetic types UPTTI notes: pilling resistance and durability are inversely related
Fibre fineness Fine denier Coarser, stiffer fibres Saraf and Tayade: fine fibres are less stiff
Yarn twist Low twist High twist Higher twist feels harder
Ply Single ply Two-ply or cabled yarn AWTA: single-ply yarn is the most likely to pill
Fabric structure Loose knit or loose weave Tight, compact fabric (for example denim); higher cover factor Saraf and Tayade: denim usually pills very little
Surface finish Hairy, unfinished surface Singed, sheared or enzyme-treated surface Enzymes cost some strength and weight

How mills reduce pilling in finishing

Saraf and Tayade list physical processes such as shearing, singeing, brushing and thermosetting; chemical treatments such as polymers or enzymes; anti-static finishes; and special treatments such as sanforizing or UV treatment. Anti-pilling finishes aim to stop fibres slipping out of the yarn, or to lower the mechanical resistance of synthetic fibres so that pills break off. For cotton knits, Cotton Incorporated names cellulase enzyme treatment, durable press resin finishing and singeing as the preventive steps that remove the fibres protruding from the yarn. Durable press resins are covered in Wrinkle-Free and Durable Press Finishing.

Cellulase biopolishing of cotton

Cellulase enzymes digest cellulose, so they can remove the surface fibres on cotton. Cotton Incorporated explains that dyeing itself can make a knit fuzzy, through fabric-to-fabric and fabric-to-machine abrasion, which is why enzymes are often applied after dyeing. Its bulletin states that the treatment is most effective after preparation and before dyeing, when the fabric can keep a clean, smooth appearance through more than 20 home laundering cycles. After dyeing, the enzyme works less well and can shift the shade, because it is removing dyed fibre.

The bulletin gives a recommended jet-machine procedure for cotton knits: acid cellulase at 2.0 g/l, buffered to pH 4.5–5.5, at 55 °C (135 °F), run for 30–60 minutes depending on fabric and machine. It warns that acid cellulase is aggressive: because the enzyme digests cellulose, there is always some loss of strength and weight, controlled through enzyme type, concentration, pH, time and temperature. Enzymes work better in a garment machine than in a jet, because there is more fabric-to-fabric contact. In a jet, the loosened fibres can stay trapped inside the knitted tube, and the tube may need to be turned and rinsed again.

The surface also affects how the colour looks. Cotton Incorporated reports a study in which black reactive-dyed interlock lost an average of 8.7% colour strength after 20 launderings. After a cellulase treatment the fabrics regained almost all of it; some went from 86.0% of their original colour strength to 98.5%. The dye had not left the fabric: the fuzz was scattering light. Related processes are covered in Enzyme Washing of Textiles and Reactive Dyes for Cotton.

Low-pill synthetic fibres

For synthetics, the fibre itself can be changed. Lecture notes on pilling and abrasion testing from UPTTI Kanpur state that polyester fibres are deliberately made brittle for knitted products, sold as anti-pilling types, so that pills can be scrubbed off instead of building up. The same notes point out the cost: pilling resistance and durability are inversely related.

How pilling is tested and graded

Laboratories speed up wear by rubbing or tumbling the fabric under controlled conditions, then compare it with visual standards. The ISO 12945-2 introduction is frank about the limits: no test accelerates fuzzing, pill formation and wear-off by exactly the same factor for every fibre, yarn and fabric. What a good test does is rank fabrics in the same order of pilling as is likely in wear.

Method How the fabric is abraded Standard or source
Modified Martindale A circular specimen is rubbed against the same fabric, or a wool abradant where relevant, in a Lissajous figure. One pilling cycle is 16 pilling rubs. Pilling, fuzzing and matting are assessed visually after defined stages. ISO 12945-2:2020 (visual assessment to ISO 12945-4); ASTM D4970
Random tumble Specimens tumble in a cylindrical chamber lined with cork, with a little cotton lint added so the pills look like those from real wear. ASTM D3512; UPTTI notes
Pilling box (ICI box) Four 125 mm × 125 mm specimens are sewn face to face into tubes, mounted on rubber tubes and tumbled together in a cork-lined box. UPTTI notes

ASTM notes that its random tumble method, D3512, suits woven and knitted apparel fabrics, but that fabrics finished with a silicone resin may give wrong results because the silicone can transfer onto the cork liners. Its Martindale method, D4970, applies to knitted and woven fabrics and, ASTM says, is used widely outside the United States. ASTM also cautions that neither method is recommended for acceptance testing between buyer and seller: for D3512 the between-laboratory precision is poor, and for D4970 interlaboratory data are not available.

Results are reported on a scale from 5 (no pilling) to 1 (very severe pilling). The UPTTI notes describe the grades like this:

  • Grade 5: no or very weak formation of pills
  • Grade 4: weak formation of pills
  • Grade 3: moderate formation of pills
  • Grade 2: obvious formation of pills
  • Grade 1: severe formation of pills

ASTM recommends judging the overall appearance, not just counting pills, because pill size, colour contrast, lint, fuzz and loss of cover all affect how acceptable the fabric looks. A buyer’s required grade, and the number of rubs or tumbling time, belong in the buyer’s own specification. For other fabric tests, see Fabric Testing: Methods, Equipment and What Results Mean.

How to prevent and remove pills on clothes you own

Woolmark’s advice is written for wool, but the logic, less rubbing, applies to any knit:

  • Turn garments inside out before washing.
  • Avoid fabric softener on wool.
  • Reduce abrasion while wearing, for example from sitting at a desk for long periods.

Woolmark accepts that nobody can guarantee a garment will not pill, so it also gives three ways to remove pills. A few pills can be picked off by hand, routinely after drying or just before ironing. A comb can be used, very gently. Small battery-operated de-pillers, or fabric shavers, are cheap and very effective. Expect the difference described above: AWTA notes that pills from natural fibres are more likely to wear or break away, while pills on strong synthetic fabrics tend to stay until they are removed.

FAQ

Does pilling mean the garment is poor quality? Not always. Pilling depends on fibre, yarn, fabric, finish and how the garment is worn. A very soft, low-twist yarn in a loose knit can pill even when the garment is well made. A grade from a standard test is a better guide than the price.

Does cotton pill? Yes, but cotton pills are more likely to break away than synthetic ones, according to AWTA. Ring-spun cotton knits are hairy, and Cotton Incorporated names cellulase, singeing and resin finishing as ways to keep the surface clean.

Why does polyester or a poly-cotton blend pill so badly? Polyester is strong, so the fibres anchoring each pill rarely break. In a blend, the weaker fibre forms the pills and the polyester holds them on. Low-pill polyester types are made deliberately brittle to change this.

Does wool pill? Yes. Woolmark says pilling is complex and can occur anywhere on a sweater, most often where the arms rub the body. It recommends longer fibres, the highest workable twist and a higher cover factor when designing wool knitwear.

What pilling grade should I ask for? The scale runs from 5 (no pilling) to 1 (very severe). The required grade, method and number of rubs are set in the buyer’s specification, so agree them before bulk production and test the same way each time.

Conclusion

Pills form when loose fibre ends tangle on the surface and stay anchored to the yarn. Short fibres, low twist, single-ply yarns, loose knits and strong synthetic fibres all push a fabric towards pilling. Long, combed fibres, higher twist, plied yarns, tighter structures, low-pill fibres and finishes such as singeing or cellulase push it away, usually at some cost to softness or strength. Decide the target grade with the buyer, test it the same way every time, and design the yarn and fabric to meet it.

Sources

Flat Knitting vs Circular Knitting: Machines, Fabric and Garments

Weft knitting can be done on two quite different machine families: circular machines, whose needles stand in a cylinder, and flat-bed machines, whose needles sit in a straight line. Both form loops course by course, as described in Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting. The difference is the shape of the needle bed. That decides whether the cloth comes off as a tube or as a panel, how many yarns can be knitted at once, and whether you are making fabric by the metre or a shaped garment.

The IIT Delhi NPTEL notes on knitting technology divide weft machines into flat-bed types (single bed, or double bed / V-bed) and circular-bed types. Errol Wood, in the University of New England lecture Machine Knitting, adds a third sector: fully fashioned straight-bar machines. This article compares the two everyday forms, circular and V-bed. Cut-and-sew, shaped panels and complete-garment knitting are covered in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting and How Sweaters Are Made.

Diagram comparing circular knitting and flat V-bed knitting machines

Circular knitting machines

CottonWorks’ Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless course describes a circular weft machine as one that pulls yarn from creels, usually beside the machine, through guides, stop motions and feeders. Needles sit in grooves, or tricks, cut into the outside of a metal cylinder. Adjacent needles knit in sequence, and the cloth is formed as a tube, which then passes over a spreader and through take-up rolls.

Machine gauge is the number of tricks per linear inch. CottonWorks notes that cylinders of the same gauge but different diameters have different total needle counts. It gives 20–44 gauge for standard knits, ultra-fine work reaching 60, and 8–28 as common for cotton. Wood writes that available circular gauges range from 5 to 32 needles per inch, mostly finer than flat machines, and that 12–22 suits wool jersey. See Knitting Machine Gauge Explained. NPTEL states the usual motion: the cam jackets are generally stationary, and the cylinder rotates. A single-jersey machine has one needle set in the cylinder; a rib or double-jersey machine adds a dial at right angles. CottonWorks calls the gap between them the dial height, and states that it directly affects stitch length, and therefore weight, width and hand. Interlock is also a circular double-jersey structure; see Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.

The practical advantage is speed. Each feeder can add a course in one revolution. CottonWorks uses a 60-feeder example; Wood gives up to 144 circular feeds, against a maximum of 8 on a flat machine. The cost, he notes, is a slight bias: when every feeder knits, the wales are not quite perpendicular to the courses. On fine-gauge wool single jersey from singles yarn he also records spirality, which may return in the wash. The usual product is a length of tubular fabric, left as a tube or split to open width, then cut and sewn. Wood lists socks, seamless underwear and T-shirts as tubular uses, each size needing a machine of the appropriate diameter. CottonWorks describes a further family of seamless circular machines with smaller, body-sized cylinders, used for hosiery, socks and activewear.

Flat-bed (V-bed) knitting machines

On a flat-bed machine the needles stand in a straight line. CottonWorks states that the needle slots stay still and a carriage carries the cams across the needles. NPTEL says the same: the needles do not move sideways; a cam jacket reciprocates laterally, the exception being the straight-bar fully fashioned machine. Wood describes industrial V-bed machines as having two flat needle beds arranged as an inverted V. The English gauge is the number of needles per inch. His Table 12.1 gives V-bed gauges of 3–18 needles per inch and a typical bed width of 200 cm (78.7 inches). Most needles are latch needles; some machines use compound needles.

NPTEL states that a single bed produces plain, or single jersey, fabric, and that a V-bed produces rib and purl, and can also knit single jersey if one bed is not used. The needles on the two beds must be offset so that they do not collide. Wood states that a flat machine can start from one cone of yarn and knit a garment, and that it can knit any width within the needle bed. Pattern can be changed over a whole panel. The beds can be racked, that is, moved parallel to each other. CottonWorks calls the racking used to shape a panel “fashioning”. This reduces yarn and scrap, but it slows the machine and locks the shape early. Typical products are sweaters and flat-knit trims, such as polo collars.

A further step is complete-garment, or integral, knitting on special V-bed machines. CottonWorks describes this as knitting a whole garment on one machine, including buttonholes, pockets, collars and hems. Production is slower and more costly than other flat-bed methods, but waste and finishing steps are reduced. The routes are compared in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting.

How the two routes compare

The useful checks are the fabric form, the number of feeds, and whether the width can be changed. The table below is a qualitative comparison from those sources, not a set of laboratory results.

Circular knitting Flat (V-bed) knitting
Yarn supply Many packages; Wood gives the example of 96 cones Can start from one cone
Needle bed Cylinder; a dial is added for rib and interlock One straight bed, or two beds in an inverted V
What moves Usually the cylinder rotates past stationary cams Needle bed stays still; the carriage and yarn carriers traverse
Fabric form Always a tube; may stay tubular or be split to open width Usually a flat panel; a tube can be knitted on both beds
Width Fixed by cylinder diameter. Wood: usually about 30 inches (76 cm), up to 60 inches (152 cm) Any width within the needle bed. Wood: typical bed 200 cm
Production, as described Continuous motion and many feeds (Wood: up to 144; examples of 60–108) Reciprocating carriage; Wood gives a maximum of 8 feeds
Patterning Possible, but Wood describes typical patterns as small, repeated motifs Pattern can be varied over a whole garment panel
Shaping Limited on fabric machines; body-size machines can shape to a degree Racking and stitch transfer used to fashion panels or complete garments
Typical products T-shirts, underwear, hosiery, socks, jersey by the metre Sweaters, cardigans, trims, scarves; also integral garments
Waste, as described Cut-and-sew from split fabric always produces some waste; Wood records up to 25% in wool knitwear Shaped panels or complete garments can reduce or eliminate cutting waste

Neither machine is automatically better. A long run of T-shirt jersey or interlock underwear is a circular job. A shaped sweater, a polo collar, a short run in an expensive yarn, or a complete knitted garment is a flat-bed job.

Practical tips for a product developer

Choose the machine family from the garment, not from habit. If the product is a cut-and-sew T-shirt, polo or jersey dress, start with a circular fabric machine. Match cylinder diameter and gauge to the finished width and the yarn. More active feeders mean more courses per revolution, but also a slightly biased course line, which matters if stripes must stay square. Plan finishing for a tube or for split open-width fabric, and allow for edge curl on single jersey after cutting.

If the product is wool singles yarn in plain jersey, take Wood’s spirality warning seriously: a coarser gauge with a two-fold yarn, or a double-jersey structure, is often safer than hoping finishing will hold the fabric flat in the wash. If the product is a sweater, cardigan, scarf or a knit trim, start on a V-bed machine. Decide early whether you will cut blanks, fashion panels, or knit a complete garment. Fashioning and integral knitting save yarn, but they slow the machine and lock the shape before knitting starts. Body-size circular machines are the usual route for many socks and seamless underwear, but they do not replace a V-bed sweater machine. Common faults on both routes are covered in Common Knitting Faults and How to Fix Them.

FAQ

Are flat knitting and circular knitting both weft knitting? Yes. In both cases the yarn is formed into loops across the fabric, course by course. The difference is the needle bed. Warp knitting is a separate family; see Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting.

Why are circular machines faster? The motion is continuous, and many feeders can knit in one revolution. Wood contrasts that with the slower reciprocating carriage of a flat machine, and with the much smaller number of feeds on a flat bed.

Can a circular machine make a sweater? Wood lists jumpers and cardigans among circular products, but they are made from fabric, usually by cutting and sewing. Shaped sweater panels and complete knitted garments are V-bed work.

Can a V-bed machine knit a tube? Yes. Wood notes that it is possible, by using the front and back needles, to produce a tube of jersey.

What is the difference between a fabric machine and a garment machine? T. Palani Rajan, in the INFLIBNET chapter Weft Knitting, uses that split: some machines produce fabric, others produce garments. A large-diameter circular jersey machine is a fabric machine. A V-bed sweater machine and a body-size seamless circular machine are used as garment machines.

Do I need a different circular machine for every T-shirt size? For tubular garments that keep the knitted width, Wood says each size needs a machine of the appropriate diameter. If the tube is split to open-width fabric, one large-diameter machine can supply several sizes, with the usual cutting waste.

Is interlock knitted on a flat machine? No. Interlock as used for underwear and base layers is a circular double-jersey structure, made with cylinder and dial needles. See Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.

Conclusion

Circular and flat weft knitting use the same loop-forming principle, and often the same latch needle. They differ in the bed, the motion, the number of feeds, and the form of the cloth. Use a circular machine when you need metres of jersey, rib or interlock, or a body-size seamless tube. Use a V-bed machine when you need a shaped panel, a trim, a short run, or a complete knitted garment. The end use, not the familiarity of one machine, should decide.

Sources

  • CottonWorks, Knit Basics (Cotton Incorporated): weft knitting by adjacent needles in sequence; circular machines forming a fabric tube, one revolution completing one course per yarn fed; flat-bed machines with needles in a straight line, one or two beds, used for sweaters, trims and scarves.
  • CottonWorks, Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless: circular creels, stop motions, feeders, tricks and gauge; spreader and take-up of the fabric tube; standard, ultra-fine and cotton gauge ranges; 60-feeder example; dial height; V-bed carriage versus stationary needle slots; racking and fashioning; seamless circular (body-size cylinders, body mapping, reciprocal knitting for socks and hosiery); integral knitting on special flat-bed machines, including carrier and four-bed description, slower and more costly production, and reduced waste.
  • NPTEL, Knitting Technology, introduction (IIT Delhi): weft machines as flat-bed (single or V-bed) or circular; cam jacket reciprocates on flat machines (exception: straight-bar); circular cams generally stationary with a rotating cylinder, or revolving cams on many small-diameter single-feeder machines; single bed for plain/jersey, V-bed for rib and purl and also for jersey; needles on two beds must be offset; circular rib uses cylinder and dial needles at right angles; interlock as two combined ribs.
  • Errol Wood, Machine Knitting, WOOL482/582 (Australian Wool Education Trust / University of New England, 2012): weft sectors (fully fashioned, V-bed, circular); feeds and yarn carriers; circular bias of courses; maximum 8 feeds on flat machines and up to 144 on circular, with examples of 96 and of 72, 96 or 108 feeders and 25–50 mm of fabric per revolution; circular gauges in the text (5–32, wool jersey 12–22) and in Table 12.1 (circular 5–40, V-bed 3–18, typical V-bed width 200 cm, circular diameter usually about 30 inches and up to 60 inches); spirality in fine singles wool jersey; cut-and-sew waste up to 25% in wool knitwear; comparison of versatility, patterning, width control, tubular versus flat fabric, and waste.
  • T. Palani Rajan, Weft Knitting, INFLIBNET e-book Textile manufacturing and testing: classification of weft knitting by machine frame (circular or flat), number of needle beds, end product (fabric machine or garment machine), basic structure and needle type.

Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting: Yarn Path, Machines and Fabrics

Weft knitting and warp knitting both make cloth by intermeshing loops of yarn. The difference is the path the yarn takes. In weft knitting, as the IIT Delhi NPTEL course on knitting technology puts it, the general direction of the yarn is across the fabric, course by course. In warp knitting the general direction is along the length. That difference decides how the yarn is supplied, whether the needles work one after another or all at once, how the fabric stretches, whether a cut edge runs, and which products the method is used for.

The three everyday weft structures are compared in Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock. Sweater production, also a weft process, is covered in How Sweaters Are Made and in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting. This article is the comparison of the two knitting families.

The official vocabularies are EVS-EN ISO 4921:2002 (ISO 4921:2000), Knitting — Basic concepts — Vocabulary, and EVS-EN ISO 8388:2003 / BS EN ISO 8388:2003, Knitted fabrics — Types — Vocabulary. The public catalogue pages give the titles, and state that ISO 4921 defines terms for basic knitting concepts, but not the definitions themselves. The descriptions below therefore come from sources that can be read in full: Cotton Incorporated’s CottonWorks knitting courses, the NPTEL notes, and Errol Wood’s machine-knitting lecture for the Australian Wool Education Trust.

Comparison diagram of weft knitting and warp knitting. On the left, one orange yarn travels across a course, with wales marked vertically. On the right, several coloured yarns zig-zag along the length between neighbouring wales. Bullet points summarise yarn supply, needle action, typical machines, products, stretch and cut-edge behaviour.
Self-made diagram for this article. It shows a weft yarn travelling across one course, and warp yarns travelling along the length and shifting between neighbouring wales.

Weft knitting

Errol Wood, in the University of New England lecture Machine Knitting, describes weft knitting as the sequential formation of a horizontal row of loops from a single yarn supplied to each needle in turn, interlinked with the row already made. NPTEL notes that this can be done from one package of yarn. A circular machine may have many feeds, but each yarn still travels across the needles in sequence.

That horizontal row is a course. The vertical column of loops made by one needle is a wale. CottonWorks’ Knit Basics course uses the same terms, and notes that a single jersey stitch has legs (the “V” on the technical face) and a crown (more visible on the technical back). NPTEL defines stitch density as the product of wales per unit width and courses per unit length, and notes that this area figure is often more reliable than either count alone, because tension in one direction can lower one reading and raise the other.

The needles work one after another. CottonWorks states that, on both circular and flat machines, adjacent needles knit in sequence to produce one row of loops from the same yarn. On a circular machine the needles stand in tricks around a cylinder, the fabric is formed as a tube, and one revolution completes one course for each yarn fed. On a flat-bed, or V-bed, machine the needles sit in a straight line on one bed, or on two beds facing each other; typical products include sweaters, trims and scarves. Machine gauge is explained in Knitting Machine Gauge Explained. Creels, stop motions and feeders are described in Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless.

Most everyday weft cloth is built from single jersey, rib and interlock. CottonWorks’ Knit Basics course characterises weft knits as having more stretch in the horizontal direction, and as fabrics that curl, run and unravel at both ends. Its Single & Double Knits course qualifies that by structure: jersey curls when cut across the width and unravels from both ends; a correctly knitted rib does not curl, but it runs from the last course; interlock is described as very stable. Common faults are covered in Common Knitting Faults and How to Fix Them. Fully fashioned panels, cut-and-sew jersey and complete-garment knitting are also weft processes: they differ in later cutting and linking, not in the yarn direction.

Warp knitting

Warp knitting forms loops in the length direction. Wood describes it as the interlinking of loops in an axial direction on a row of needles, with at least one separate thread supplied to each needle, the threads moving back and forth between adjacent needles to join the fabric in width. Unlike weft knitting, he notes, there is no manual equivalent of machine warp knitting.

NPTEL states the practical consequence: warp knitting needs a warp beam, not a single package. CottonWorks’ Knit Machinery course gives the factory picture. Yarns are wound onto beams and fed vertically; a basic fabric needs at least one yarn for every needle, so a machine with a thousand needles needs a minimum of a thousand warp ends. The needle bed moves up and down together, and guide bars wrap the yarns around the needles. All the needles knit at once, which is why the machines can run at high speed once they are threaded. That threading is labour-intensive, and CottonWorks notes that long production runs are needed to make it efficient.

Courses and wales are still the horizontal rows and vertical columns, but a warp yarn does not stay in one course. It travels along the fabric in a slight zig-zag, shifting between neighbouring wales.

CottonWorks divides warp machines into two main families. Tricot machines, it says, produce relatively flat commodity warp knits, in a finer gauge, with more vertical stretch. They use spring-beard, latch or compound needles and two to eight guide bars. The yarns are described as fine filament or textured filament, not spun, and the structures as plain cloth, simple designs and small geometric patterns. CottonWorks states that tricot machines can knit at up to 2,000 stitches per minute, and that tricot without elastane can behave as a woven substitute: less stretch than a typical weft knit, but with knit drape and a high tensile strength for its weight. Listed end uses are automotive upholstery, footwear, intimate apparel, swimwear and activewear.

Raschel machines are described as more versatile. They can knit spun yarns, filament, textured filament and cotton, and CottonWorks states that they can have up to eight guide bars and jacquard attachments, with a published speed of up to 1,300 stitches per minute and the same intensive set-up as tricot. Stretch can be controlled by where elastane is placed in the guide bars. The structure is described as strong and not apt to run or tear easily, even in open meshes, so a panel can be cut to length without the edge running. Typical products listed are laces, spacer fabrics, netting, and fabrics for swimwear, activewear and upholstery. The same run-resistant warp-knit structures are also used for knitted protective fabric and garments.

CottonWorks also notes that warp machines work primarily with synthetic filament yarns because of the high friction in the process; cotton, when used, is often knitted in a coarser warp gauge. Warp knits are often cross-dyed, and an ultra-fine capability of 50 gauge is recorded. Within the wool industry, Wood adds, warp knitting is seldom used.

Yarn path, stretch and a cut edge

The useful check is to follow a yarn, then look at a cut edge. In a weft fabric a yarn can be followed across a course; in a warp fabric each yarn runs along the length, stepping from one wale to a neighbour. NPTEL’s module FAQ states that a weft construction is expected to show lower modulus and higher elastic stretch along the course than along the wale, and the reverse in a warp construction. CottonWorks says the same in factory language: weft knits have more horizontal stretch; warp-knit extensibility runs length-wise. It also states that warp-knitted fabrics do not fray or curl if cut horizontally, and that they can be made very fine, which suits hosiery and intimates. Raschel meshes can likewise be cut without running.

The table below is a qualitative comparison from those sources, not a set of laboratory results.

Weft knittingWarp knitting
Yarn supplyOne or more packages; can start from a single packageWarp beam(s); at least one yarn per needle
Needle actionAdjacent needles knit in sequenceNeedles knit simultaneously; guide bars wrap the yarns
Yarn pathAcross the fabric, course by courseAlong the fabric, shifting between neighbouring wales
Stretch, as describedHigher elastic stretch along the courseHigher stretch along the wale (length-wise)
Cut edgeDepends on structure: jersey curls and unravels; rib and interlock differDoes not fray or curl if cut horizontally; raschel meshes described as run-resistant
Typical machinesCircular (fabric tube) and flat or V-bedTricot and raschel
Typical productsT-shirts, polos, sweaters, socks, rib trimsTricot: intimates, swimwear, activewear, automotive, footwear. Raschel: lace, mesh, spacers, netting

Neither family is automatically better. A T-shirt, a rib cuff or a shaped sweater is a weft product. A lingerie tricot, a lace, a spacer or a long run of automotive lining is usually a warp product. The end use decides.

FAQ

What is the main difference between weft and warp knitting? The yarn path. In weft knitting the yarn travels across the fabric and adjacent needles knit in sequence, so a course can be made from one yarn. In warp knitting a sheet of yarns is fed along the length, at least one to each needle, and each yarn zig-zags between neighbouring wales.

Can warp knitting be done by hand? No. Wood states that there is no manual equivalent to machine warp knitting. Hand knitting, and domestic flat machines, are weft processes.

Do warp knits unravel like a T-shirt? Not in the same way. CottonWorks states that warp-knitted fabrics do not fray or curl if cut horizontally, and that raschel meshes can be cut to length without running. A plain weft jersey does curl and can unravel from both ends.

Is interlock a warp knit? No. Interlock is a weft-knit structure made on two needle beds. See Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.

Why do warp machines take so long to set up? A full set of warp ends has to be threaded through the guide bars. CottonWorks notes that a machine with a thousand needles needs at least a thousand yarns for a basic fabric, and that long runs are needed to justify that labour. Once threaded, every needle knits at once, so the machines run at high speed.

Can cotton be warp knitted? Yes, with limits. CottonWorks says cotton is often used in coarser-gauge warp knitting, and that raschel machines can knit spun yarns and cotton. It describes tricot yarns as fine or textured filament, not spun.

Is complete-garment, or WHOLEGARMENT, knitting a warp process? No. It is a weft process on special flat-bed machines. See WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting.

Sources

  • - CottonWorks, Knit Basics (Cotton Incorporated): definition of knits; courses and wales; legs and crowns; knit, tuck and float stitches; weft knitting (sequential needles, circular tube and flat bed; horizontal stretch; curling, running and unravelling); warp knitting (one yarn per needle, simultaneous knitting, beams, vertical stretch, no fray or curl if cut horizontally; tricot, raschel and crochet; long set-up and high speed).
  • - CottonWorks, Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless: circular creels, feeders and fabric tube; tricks, verge and circular gauge; latch-needle cycle; V-bed products; warp knitting with guide bars; tricot and raschel needle types, guide bars, published speed figures, yarn types and end uses; cut-resistant raschel meshes.
  • - CottonWorks, Single & Double Knits: jersey, rib and interlock properties, including curling, unravelling and stability.
  • - NPTEL, Knitting Technology, basic concepts (IIT Delhi): weft yarn path across the fabric and warp yarn path along the length; weft from one package, warp from a beam; definitions of wale, course, wale-spacing, course-spacing and stitch density; William Lee, 1589, is also recorded here but is not relied on in the article.
  • - NPTEL, Knitting Technology, Module 1 FAQ: weft construction expected to show higher elastic stretch along the course than the wale, and the reverse in a warp construction; interlooping of different yarns in warp knitting versus intralooping in a plain weft construction.
  • - Errol Wood, Machine Knitting, WOOL482/582 (Australian Wool Education Trust / University of New England, 2012): weft and warp definitions; no manual equivalent of warp knitting; warp knitting seldom used for wool; tricot described as a warp-knitted fabric made with two sets of warp threads, used for swimwear, active garments and foundation wear.
  • - EVS-EN ISO 4921:2002: public catalogue; official scope is that the standard defines terms for basic knitting concepts.
  • - EVS-EN ISO 8388:2003 / BS EN ISO 8388:2003: public catalogues for Knitted fabrics — Types — Vocabulary (ISO 8388:1998). The BSI descriptors include weft knitting and warp-knitting machines. The full definitions are not on the public pages and are not quoted here.