Weft Knitting vs Warp Knitting: Yarn Path, Machines and Fabrics

Weft knitting and warp knitting both make cloth by intermeshing loops of yarn. The difference is the path the yarn takes. In weft knitting, as the IIT Delhi NPTEL course on knitting technology puts it, the general direction of the yarn is across the fabric, course by course. In warp knitting the general direction is along the length. That difference decides how the yarn is supplied, whether the needles work one after another or all at once, how the fabric stretches, whether a cut edge runs, and which products the method is used for.

The three everyday weft structures are compared in Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock. Sweater production, also a weft process, is covered in How Sweaters Are Made and in WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting. This article is the comparison of the two knitting families.

The official vocabularies are EVS-EN ISO 4921:2002 (ISO 4921:2000), Knitting — Basic concepts — Vocabulary, and EVS-EN ISO 8388:2003 / BS EN ISO 8388:2003, Knitted fabrics — Types — Vocabulary. The public catalogue pages give the titles, and state that ISO 4921 defines terms for basic knitting concepts, but not the definitions themselves. The descriptions below therefore come from sources that can be read in full: Cotton Incorporated’s CottonWorks knitting courses, the NPTEL notes, and Errol Wood’s machine-knitting lecture for the Australian Wool Education Trust.

Comparison diagram of weft knitting and warp knitting. On the left, one orange yarn travels across a course, with wales marked vertically. On the right, several coloured yarns zig-zag along the length between neighbouring wales. Bullet points summarise yarn supply, needle action, typical machines, products, stretch and cut-edge behaviour.
Self-made diagram for this article. It shows a weft yarn travelling across one course, and warp yarns travelling along the length and shifting between neighbouring wales.

Weft knitting

Errol Wood, in the University of New England lecture Machine Knitting, describes weft knitting as the sequential formation of a horizontal row of loops from a single yarn supplied to each needle in turn, interlinked with the row already made. NPTEL notes that this can be done from one package of yarn. A circular machine may have many feeds, but each yarn still travels across the needles in sequence.

That horizontal row is a course. The vertical column of loops made by one needle is a wale. CottonWorks’ Knit Basics course uses the same terms, and notes that a single jersey stitch has legs (the “V” on the technical face) and a crown (more visible on the technical back). NPTEL defines stitch density as the product of wales per unit width and courses per unit length, and notes that this area figure is often more reliable than either count alone, because tension in one direction can lower one reading and raise the other.

The needles work one after another. CottonWorks states that, on both circular and flat machines, adjacent needles knit in sequence to produce one row of loops from the same yarn. On a circular machine the needles stand in tricks around a cylinder, the fabric is formed as a tube, and one revolution completes one course for each yarn fed. On a flat-bed, or V-bed, machine the needles sit in a straight line on one bed, or on two beds facing each other; typical products include sweaters, trims and scarves. Machine gauge is explained in Knitting Machine Gauge Explained. Creels, stop motions and feeders are described in Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless.

Most everyday weft cloth is built from single jersey, rib and interlock. CottonWorks’ Knit Basics course characterises weft knits as having more stretch in the horizontal direction, and as fabrics that curl, run and unravel at both ends. Its Single & Double Knits course qualifies that by structure: jersey curls when cut across the width and unravels from both ends; a correctly knitted rib does not curl, but it runs from the last course; interlock is described as very stable. Common faults are covered in Common Knitting Faults and How to Fix Them. Fully fashioned panels, cut-and-sew jersey and complete-garment knitting are also weft processes: they differ in later cutting and linking, not in the yarn direction.

Warp knitting

Warp knitting forms loops in the length direction. Wood describes it as the interlinking of loops in an axial direction on a row of needles, with at least one separate thread supplied to each needle, the threads moving back and forth between adjacent needles to join the fabric in width. Unlike weft knitting, he notes, there is no manual equivalent of machine warp knitting.

NPTEL states the practical consequence: warp knitting needs a warp beam, not a single package. CottonWorks’ Knit Machinery course gives the factory picture. Yarns are wound onto beams and fed vertically; a basic fabric needs at least one yarn for every needle, so a machine with a thousand needles needs a minimum of a thousand warp ends. The needle bed moves up and down together, and guide bars wrap the yarns around the needles. All the needles knit at once, which is why the machines can run at high speed once they are threaded. That threading is labour-intensive, and CottonWorks notes that long production runs are needed to make it efficient.

Courses and wales are still the horizontal rows and vertical columns, but a warp yarn does not stay in one course. It travels along the fabric in a slight zig-zag, shifting between neighbouring wales.

CottonWorks divides warp machines into two main families. Tricot machines, it says, produce relatively flat commodity warp knits, in a finer gauge, with more vertical stretch. They use spring-beard, latch or compound needles and two to eight guide bars. The yarns are described as fine filament or textured filament, not spun, and the structures as plain cloth, simple designs and small geometric patterns. CottonWorks states that tricot machines can knit at up to 2,000 stitches per minute, and that tricot without elastane can behave as a woven substitute: less stretch than a typical weft knit, but with knit drape and a high tensile strength for its weight. Listed end uses are automotive upholstery, footwear, intimate apparel, swimwear and activewear.

Raschel machines are described as more versatile. They can knit spun yarns, filament, textured filament and cotton, and CottonWorks states that they can have up to eight guide bars and jacquard attachments, with a published speed of up to 1,300 stitches per minute and the same intensive set-up as tricot. Stretch can be controlled by where elastane is placed in the guide bars. The structure is described as strong and not apt to run or tear easily, even in open meshes, so a panel can be cut to length without the edge running. Typical products listed are laces, spacer fabrics, netting, and fabrics for swimwear, activewear and upholstery.

CottonWorks also notes that warp machines work primarily with synthetic filament yarns because of the high friction in the process; cotton, when used, is often knitted in a coarser warp gauge. Warp knits are often cross-dyed, and an ultra-fine capability of 50 gauge is recorded. Within the wool industry, Wood adds, warp knitting is seldom used.

Yarn path, stretch and a cut edge

The useful check is to follow a yarn, then look at a cut edge. In a weft fabric a yarn can be followed across a course; in a warp fabric each yarn runs along the length, stepping from one wale to a neighbour. NPTEL’s module FAQ states that a weft construction is expected to show lower modulus and higher elastic stretch along the course than along the wale, and the reverse in a warp construction. CottonWorks says the same in factory language: weft knits have more horizontal stretch; warp-knit extensibility runs length-wise. It also states that warp-knitted fabrics do not fray or curl if cut horizontally, and that they can be made very fine, which suits hosiery and intimates. Raschel meshes can likewise be cut without running.

The table below is a qualitative comparison from those sources, not a set of laboratory results.

Weft knittingWarp knitting
Yarn supplyOne or more packages; can start from a single packageWarp beam(s); at least one yarn per needle
Needle actionAdjacent needles knit in sequenceNeedles knit simultaneously; guide bars wrap the yarns
Yarn pathAcross the fabric, course by courseAlong the fabric, shifting between neighbouring wales
Stretch, as describedHigher elastic stretch along the courseHigher stretch along the wale (length-wise)
Cut edgeDepends on structure: jersey curls and unravels; rib and interlock differDoes not fray or curl if cut horizontally; raschel meshes described as run-resistant
Typical machinesCircular (fabric tube) and flat or V-bedTricot and raschel
Typical productsT-shirts, polos, sweaters, socks, rib trimsTricot: intimates, swimwear, activewear, automotive, footwear. Raschel: lace, mesh, spacers, netting

Neither family is automatically better. A T-shirt, a rib cuff or a shaped sweater is a weft product. A lingerie tricot, a lace, a spacer or a long run of automotive lining is usually a warp product. The end use decides.

FAQ

What is the main difference between weft and warp knitting? The yarn path. In weft knitting the yarn travels across the fabric and adjacent needles knit in sequence, so a course can be made from one yarn. In warp knitting a sheet of yarns is fed along the length, at least one to each needle, and each yarn zig-zags between neighbouring wales.

Can warp knitting be done by hand? No. Wood states that there is no manual equivalent to machine warp knitting. Hand knitting, and domestic flat machines, are weft processes.

Do warp knits unravel like a T-shirt? Not in the same way. CottonWorks states that warp-knitted fabrics do not fray or curl if cut horizontally, and that raschel meshes can be cut to length without running. A plain weft jersey does curl and can unravel from both ends.

Is interlock a warp knit? No. Interlock is a weft-knit structure made on two needle beds. See Single Jersey vs Rib vs Interlock.

Why do warp machines take so long to set up? A full set of warp ends has to be threaded through the guide bars. CottonWorks notes that a machine with a thousand needles needs at least a thousand yarns for a basic fabric, and that long runs are needed to justify that labour. Once threaded, every needle knits at once, so the machines run at high speed.

Can cotton be warp knitted? Yes, with limits. CottonWorks says cotton is often used in coarser-gauge warp knitting, and that raschel machines can knit spun yarns and cotton. It describes tricot yarns as fine or textured filament, not spun.

Is complete-garment, or WHOLEGARMENT, knitting a warp process? No. It is a weft process on special flat-bed machines. See WHOLEGARMENT vs Fully Fashioned vs Cut-and-Sew Knitting.

Sources

  • - CottonWorks, Knit Basics (Cotton Incorporated): definition of knits; courses and wales; legs and crowns; knit, tuck and float stitches; weft knitting (sequential needles, circular tube and flat bed; horizontal stretch; curling, running and unravelling); warp knitting (one yarn per needle, simultaneous knitting, beams, vertical stretch, no fray or curl if cut horizontally; tricot, raschel and crochet; long set-up and high speed).
  • - CottonWorks, Knit Machinery: Flat, Circular, and Seamless: circular creels, feeders and fabric tube; tricks, verge and circular gauge; latch-needle cycle; V-bed products; warp knitting with guide bars; tricot and raschel needle types, guide bars, published speed figures, yarn types and end uses; cut-resistant raschel meshes.
  • - CottonWorks, Single & Double Knits: jersey, rib and interlock properties, including curling, unravelling and stability.
  • - NPTEL, Knitting Technology, basic concepts (IIT Delhi): weft yarn path across the fabric and warp yarn path along the length; weft from one package, warp from a beam; definitions of wale, course, wale-spacing, course-spacing and stitch density; William Lee, 1589, is also recorded here but is not relied on in the article.
  • - NPTEL, Knitting Technology, Module 1 FAQ: weft construction expected to show higher elastic stretch along the course than the wale, and the reverse in a warp construction; interlooping of different yarns in warp knitting versus intralooping in a plain weft construction.
  • - Errol Wood, Machine Knitting, WOOL482/582 (Australian Wool Education Trust / University of New England, 2012): weft and warp definitions; no manual equivalent of warp knitting; warp knitting seldom used for wool; tricot described as a warp-knitted fabric made with two sets of warp threads, used for swimwear, active garments and foundation wear.
  • - EVS-EN ISO 4921:2002: public catalogue; official scope is that the standard defines terms for basic knitting concepts.
  • - EVS-EN ISO 8388:2003 / BS EN ISO 8388:2003: public catalogues for Knitted fabrics — Types — Vocabulary (ISO 8388:1998). The BSI descriptors include weft knitting and warp-knitting machines. The full definitions are not on the public pages and are not quoted here.

No comments:

Post a Comment